Home › Save money on healthcare
How to Save Money on Healthcare (Even When You Have Insurance)
Written and reviewed by Dick Tracy, licensed health insurance broker (NPN 20414610) · Published August 31, 2026
You save money on healthcare the same way you save money on everything else: find out the real price before you buy. Ask for the cash price before you hand over your insurance card, because it is often lower than what your plan would leave you paying. Never pay the first price on a prescription. And when a bill shows up, match it against your EOB before you pay a dime, because billing errors are common and an error is not your debt. I put every tool I use into a free Resource Kit you can save to your phone. No app store, no login, no email address required.
I'm Dick Tracy, an independent health insurance broker in Western New York, licensed in 25 states with 80+ carriers behind me. I came out of the healthcare side of this business: billing codes, prior authorizations, the works. So there is no gag clause on me, and I will give you the tips, the tricks, and the traps. This page is the traps-and-tricks half. Most people never learn that healthcare has two price tags, the insurance price and the cash price, and that you are allowed to look at both. Here is how.
Step 1: Ask for the cash price before you use your insurance
I shop healthcare the way I shop for a TV at Walmart: I look at the price tag first. Every provider has a cash price, and for imaging, lab work, and plenty of outpatient procedures it can come in under your plan's negotiated rate, sometimes under your copay. On MDsave you can see the real cash price for a procedure near you and book it online at that price. Prepay imaging and lab services do the same thing for MRIs, CT scans, X-rays, and bloodwork. The full list of the tools I use lives in the kit below. The habit is what matters: before you book anything that is not an emergency, ask one question. What is the cash price?
Step 2: Never pay the first price on a prescription
The same drug can cost wildly different amounts at two pharmacies in the same town, and your copay is not automatically the best deal. Check a cash coupon site like GoodRx before you fill anything; the coupon price often beats the copay. On a brand-name drug, go one better: check the manufacturer's website for a copay savings card. Most brands have one, and it can drop your cost to as little as $0 to $25 a month. Those cards work with marketplace and employer plans, not with Medicare or Medicaid. And at the counter, ask the pharmacist for the cash price. In many states they cannot volunteer it, but they can answer when you ask.
The insider move: pay cash, then bill your own insurance
Here is one almost nobody tells you, and it is the reason the front desk saying "you can't pay cash, you have insurance" is nonsense. Paying cash is legal. It is not fraud. When the cash price wins, pay it, then ask for an itemized receipt (the billing office calls it a superbill) and submit it to your own insurance company yourself. The plan processes it like any claim, and depending on your benefits, the payment can land on the right side of the ledger: I have seen the benefit pay more than the cash price the person spent, so they finished the appointment with a check instead of a bill. Ask me how that works and I will walk you through it.
When a bill shows up, do not pay it yet
A medical bill is a first draft, not a verdict. Wait for the Explanation of Benefits from your insurance company, then match the bill against it line by line. If the provider billed you before the EOB even exists, that alone tells you something is off. Ask for an itemized bill and look at the codes, because coding errors are common and an error is not your debt. If the bill is real but too big, ask the billing office about a self-pay discount, financial assistance, or an interest-free payment plan; hospitals have all of them and give them to the people who ask. And if you got a surprise out-of-network bill from an in-network hospital or an emergency, the federal No Surprises Act limits what they can charge you. Do not just pay it because it looks official.
Grab the free Resource Kit (it lives on your phone)
Everything on this page, plus the full toolbox, in one free mini app you save to your home screen:
- 🔍 The cash price lookup tools for procedures, imaging, and lab work
- 💊 The prescription savings tools, including the copay card trick
- 🧾 A walk-through for what to do with a confusing medical bill
- ❓ Plain-English answers to the questions I get asked the most
- 📞 My card: text me, email me, or book a call in two taps
No app store. No login. No email address. Nothing to pay. Open the link, then choose "Add to Home Screen" (the share button on iPhone, the browser menu on Android) and it sits on your phone like any app, ready the next time a bill or a prescription surprises you.
🎒 Save the free Resource Kit to your phoneCommon questions about saving money on healthcare
Is paying cash for healthcare cheaper than using insurance?
Often, yes, especially for imaging, lab work, outpatient procedures, and everyday prescriptions. Providers set a cash price that skips the insurance billing machine, and it can come in under your plan's negotiated rate, sometimes under your copay. And it is completely legal. Paying cash is not insurance fraud, no matter what a front desk tells you. The smart move is to check both numbers before you book: ask the provider for the cash price, then compare it to what your plan would leave you paying. Whichever is lower wins.
How much does an MRI cost without insurance?
It depends entirely on where you go, and that is the whole trick. The same MRI can generate a bill for thousands of dollars through a hospital and sell for a few hundred dollars cash at an independent imaging center. Before you book any scan, look up the real cash price on a site like MDsave or a prepay imaging service and compare it to what your plan would leave you paying. Shopping the scan like you would shop a TV is often the single biggest one-time savings in healthcare.
How do I save money on prescriptions?
Never pay the first price. The same drug can swing wildly between pharmacies, so check a cash coupon site like GoodRx before you fill anything, because the coupon price often beats your copay. On a brand-name drug, check the manufacturer's website for a copay savings card first. Most brands have one and it can drop your cost to as little as $0 to $25 a month on marketplace and employer plans (they do not work with Medicare or Medicaid). And always ask the pharmacist one question: what is the cash price? They can rarely volunteer it, but they can answer it.
Can I negotiate a medical bill?
Yes, and you should never pay a big bill without checking it first. Ask for an itemized bill, then match it line by line against the Explanation of Benefits from your insurance company. Billing and coding errors are common, and an error is not your debt. If the bill is accurate but too big, ask the billing office about a self-pay discount, a prompt-pay discount, financial assistance, or an interest-free payment plan. Hospitals have all four and hand them out to the people who ask. For surprise out-of-network bills from an in-network facility or an emergency, the federal No Surprises Act limits what they can charge you.
What is in the free healthcare Resource Kit?
The kit is a free mini web app you save to your phone's home screen. Inside: the cash price lookup tools for procedures, imaging, and labs, the prescription savings tools, a walk-through for handling a confusing medical bill, plain-English answers to the most common insurance and healthcare questions, and my contact card with a button to text me, email me, or book a call. There is no app store download, no login, no email address required, and nothing to pay. It is the same toolbox I use with my own clients.
Send it my way and I will decode it with you: what the codes mean, what the EOB says, and what to push back on. No hard sell, ever. I educate, you decide.
Grab a time right here
Pick a slot below and it lands on both our calendars. No phone tag, no hard sell. I educate, you decide.